How to Sell Car Insurance

Written by: Nik Ventouris

Last updated:

How to Sell Car Insurance

Selling car insurance can be a rewarding and lucrative career choice.

As an agent, you’ll have the opportunity to help people safeguard their vehicles and finances while earning a steady income.

If you’re an insurance agent looking to improve your car insurance sales or considering entering the field, our How to Sell Car Insurance guide will provide valuable insights and strategies in order to help you succeed.

How to Sell Car Insurance Successfully

To excel in selling insurance, a combination of strategic planning, skillful execution, and continuous learning is essential. Among the various strategies, insurance agent digital marketing has emerged as a powerful tool to increase sales.

Digital Marketing for Car Insurance Sales

In today’s tech-savvy world, people often turn to the internet to find suitable car insurance options. As a licensed insurance agent, leveraging digital marketing can help you reach more potential clients and boost your sales.

Social Media

Social media platforms can be an effective way to connect with potential clients and grow your business.

  • Know your audience: Identify the social media channels most used by your target audience and establish your presence there
  • Engage actively: Post informative and relevant content regularly, respond to queries, and interact with your followers. This will help you build trust and foster relationships
  • Run targeted ads: Utilize tools provided by platforms like Facebook for ad targeting, allowing you to reach individuals who are likely to need car insurance

Note: Remember that consistent posting and tailored content are both key to your social media marketing campaign’s success. This is because frequently sharing relatable, audience-specific information will allow you to effectively engage potential clients, driving trust and fostering long-term relationships in the property and casualty insurance market.

Recommended Service

As a property and casualty insurance agent, we recommend working with Arrow; Arrow uses AI in order to offer up to five personalized posts a week, online traffic boosts, and weekly reporting.

4.5 out of 5 starsArrow Now ($49 per month)

Content Marketing

Content marketing is a long-term strategy that involves creating and sharing valuable content in order to attract and convert prospects.

Such content usually includes blog posts, press releases, articles, videos, and other forms of information that can be used to indirectly advertise your products while sharing valuable information with your target audience.

All in all, you can use content marketing in order to:

  • Educate your audience: Develop blog posts, press releases, or videos that explain different aspects of car insurance, such as coverage types, discounts, and claims processes
  • Share success stories: Narrate instances where clients benefited from their car insurance policies. These stories can demonstrate the tangible value of insurance to prospects
  • Optimize for SEO: Implement SEO strategies to make your content easily discoverable on search engines like Google

Recommended: If you are interested in boost-starting your content marketing campaign, have a look at Sitetrail’s premium press release services.

Pay-Per-Click Advertising

Pay-per-click (PPC) advertising can be an efficient way to drive traffic to your website, increase visibility, and is also extremely measurable.

This is because — with PPC advertising — you will only be charged when a user actually clicks on your ad, meaning that you will be able to determine how many “clicks” it takes to generate one sale.

In order to reap the best results with your PPC ads, you will need to:

  • Use strategic keywords: Identify and bid on keywords that potential clients might use when searching for car insurance
  • Create compelling ads: Write ad copy that highlights the benefits of your insurance plans and motivates people to click
  • Monitor campaign performance: Use analytics tools to track the ads that deliver the best results, and adjust your campaigns accordingly

Building a Website

Nowadays, building a professional website is not only recommended but an outright requirement.

This is because it is essential in relation to making you seem more trustworthy and legitimate online, and can also be used to advertise your other marketing channels (e.g., social media, blog, etc.).

You can use your business website in order to:

  • Showcase your products: Provide detailed information about the car insurance policies you offer, allowing prospects to make informed decisions
  • Offer valuable resources: Share informative articles, videos, or infographics that address common car insurance questions or concerns

Make it easy to contact you: Include contact forms, email addresses, or phone numbers so potential clients can easily reach out to you.

Recommended Software

We recommend the GoDaddy Website Builder as a small insurance agent company. GoDaddy meets most small business needs while providing an extremely straightforward user experience.

Email Marketing

Email marketing is a powerful tool for reaching out to potential clients and keeping your current clients informed.

  • Stay connected: Regular newsletters can provide useful tips and updates about car insurance policies, maintaining a line of communication with your clients and prospects
  • Personalize your approach: Tailored emails that address the recipient’s specific needs or preferences can create a stronger connection and increase engagement. For example, you could send reminders about upcoming policy renewals, personalized policy recommendations, or targeted promotional offers
  • Measure your success: Use email marketing analytics to track open rates, click-through rates, and conversions. This can help you understand what types of content and strategies are most effective

Affiliate Marketing

Affiliate marketing can significantly expand your reach and attract new prospects to your car insurance products.

  • Form strategic partnerships: Collaborate with relevant websites, influencers, or referral partners to promote your car insurance plans. For example, you could partner with a popular car blog, a local car dealership, or a respected financial advisor
  • Offer incentives: Provide your affiliates with a commission for each client they refer to you. This can motivate them to actively promote your products
  • Monitor your affiliates: Use affiliate tracking software to see which partners are generating the most leads and sales. This can help you focus your efforts on the most successful partnerships

Tips for Selling Car Insurance

In order to be successful in car insurance sales, you will need more than just marketing tactics.

Try implementing some of the tips we’ve included below to help further enhance your insurance selling.

Understand Your Products Inside and Out

It is crucial to have a thorough understanding of the car insurance policies you’re selling, such as their coverage limits, deductibles, and any exclusions or special features.

This knowledge will allow you to confidently answer any questions your clients have and help them find the policy that best fits their needs.

Know Your Clients

In addition to your products, it’s important to possess an understanding of your client’s unique needs and preferences as this is what enables you to match them with the right car insurance policy (e.g. comprehensive or collision insurance).

To find out more about your clients, try asking detailed questions about their driving habits, vehicle details, and financial situation. This will enable you to provide tailored advice and demonstrate that you truly care about their well-being.

Build Trust and Cultivate Relationships

Establishing and maintaining relationships with clients is a central part of generating repeat business and boosting insurance sales in the long run.

To build the trust necessary for this, make sure to always be honest, transparent, and responsive. Treat each interaction as an opportunity to show your clients that you’re there to support them, not just to make a sale.

Continuously Learn and Adapt

Finally, it is vital to stay up to date with the car insurance industry due to its ever-evolving nature. This will enable you to continuously improve your skills and adapt your sales strategies to meet the changing needs of your clients.

Attending industry training sessions, seminars, and networking are all great ways to make sure you’re informed about new products, changes in regulations, and shifts in consumer behavior.

Recommended: For more information on specific selling tips and strategies, have a look at our general How to Sell Insurance article.

How to Become an Auto Insurance Agent

Getting an insurance license in your state is more than just a necessity, it is a legal requirement before you can start selling auto insurance.

Even though the specific process for this can vary from state to state, you will generally need to complete the following steps in order to get licensed:

  • Complete a pre-licensing education course in your state: This is a legal requirement in most states; even where it is not required, we recommend purchasing a course in order to ensure that you pass your exam on your first attempt; this can end up saving you both money and time
  • Take your state’s property and casualty insurance licensing exam: States’ insurance exams are generally administered by Pearson VUE, PSI, or Prometric. Line-specific outlines are offered to help with your preparation. Keep in mind that you can get licensed in more than one insurance line (e.g., health insurance, etc.)
  • Get a fingerprinting and/or background check: The exact fee for this will be dependent on your state, but is generally less than $100
  • File an official license application: You can usually do this with your state’s Department of Insurance. This office can also be known as the Division of Insurance depending on your location

Recommended: For more information, we recommend having a look at our state-specific How to Become an Insurance Agent article.

How to Sell Car Insurance FAQ

What license do I need to sell car insurance?

In order to sell insurance, you’ll be required to obtain a property and casualty insurance license. This process generally involves completing a state-approved pre-licensing course that covers relevant insurance principles and state-specific insurance laws. After this, you will need to pass your state’s licensing exam, before filing an application with your state’s Department of Insurance. See our How to Sell Insurance article for more information.

Is the property and casualty insurance exam difficult?

The difficulty of the property and casualty insurance exam can vary depending on the individual. It covers a broad range of insurance concepts, terms, and state-specific laws and regulations. But don’t worry — with diligent study, the use of practice exams, and a comprehensive understanding of the course material — many candidates successfully pass the exam. For more information on getting started, have a look at our Property and Casualty License article.

How can I sell car insurance?

In order to sell car insurance, you will need to obtain a property and casualty insurance license. You will then be able to join an existing insurance company as an agent or start your own independent agency. Keep in mind that you will need to learn how to effectively market your products online via a plethora of different digital marketing strategies (e.g., social media, PPC, etc.).

How do auto insurance agents make money?

Auto insurance agencies primarily earn money through commissions, which are a percentage of the premiums that clients pay for the policies the agent sells. Some agents may also receive bonuses for meeting sales targets. Therefore, the more policies an agent sells and renews, the higher their earnings will be. Some agents also provide more personalized services for additional fees.